Lost in Wing Chun’s Simplicity

October 7, 2008

Because of Bruce Lee wing chun has become such a hugely popular style around the world. And because Yip Man was Lee’s teacher, the Hong Kong style of wing chun became the most well-known and widely practiced of the wing chun branches. Yet, after Yip passed away so many of his students claimed to be grandmaster, including: William Cheung, Leung Ting, Moy Yat… to name a few. So what’s the difference?

I began my journey in wing chun in 1985 in William Cheung’s system. Then six years later changed to Yip Man’s system. Then on to the so-called Jun Fan method of Bruce Lee… and finally now for the past decade I have been training with Robert Chu whenever we see each other. And even with a large collection of wing chun books in my library, 23 years in the art, so many teachers, and having been editor on Rene Ritchie and Robert Chu’s book “Complete Wing Chun” and Rene’s “Yuen Kay San Wing Chun” book… I still have not grasped this system! Have I gotten lost in wing chun’s simplicity?

Maybe all my eskrima training makes the chi sao movements so difficult for me, since eskrima’s sword and dagger are applied just the opposite? Maybe the press has made the art more obscure than it really is, especially for intellectuals like me who think too much?

Speaking of which, in July of 1992 “Black Belt” magazine published an article I wrote on wing chun. It was originally titled “Fighting Principles of Wing Chun,” but they added a picture of Bruce Lee and changed the title to be controversial to sell copies.

So, they drummed up readership by making a difference between wing chun and ving tsun (Hong Kong spelling). And of course Leung Ting combines the two to differentiate his wing tsun. And yet, the styles of Cheung, Moy and Ting are so similar and all derive from the same teacher, Yip Man.

With so many branches of wing chun out there, much more complex and curriculum heavy than the Hong Kong lineage, why do we cling so hard to name and teacher? Well, for me personally, I cannot wait to meet and train with Por Suk in the Hay Bun system! Maybe this time, I will grasp something essential and finally become… skilled. 🙂

Hope you enjoy this old article… despite the added hoopla!

Mark

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: